When asking yourself about something to do near me in New York with a group of friends or family, consider
Carnegie Pizza
Why Carnegie Pizza is a fun option when searching for things to do near me with friends and family
Carnegie Pizza, located in the heart of Manhattan at 200 West 41st Street, offers a quintessential New York pizza experience that makes it an excellent place to meet up with friends. Known for its classic thin-crust slices, clean and well-lit atmosphere, and friendly service, Carnegie Pizza is a popular choice among locals and tourists alike. Whether grabbing a quick bite after work or enjoying a casual gathering, its proximity to Times Square and bustling Midtown makes it a convenient and inviting location. The menu provides a variety of options including traditional cheese, pepperoni, barbecue chicken, and the beloved white pizza, catering to diverse tastes. The pizza is praised for a nicely crisp and crunchy bottom, with a balanced sauce and cheese ratio, making every bite flavorful without overwhelming greasiness. The restaurant also offers both indoor and sidewalk seating, perfect for enjoying pizza and good company in the vibrant city setting. Many reviewers highlight Carnegie Pizza's steady quality and consistency, making it a reliable spot for satisfying late-night cravings or casual lunches with friends in Manhattan.
Here's what people think of Carnegie Pizza
As of recent, Carnegie Pizza holds a 4.6-star rating based on 1683 reviews.
User reviews for Carnegie Pizza reflect a generally positive consensus with an average rating of 4.6 from over 1,600 reviews. Many reviewers appreciate the clean and inviting restaurant environment, along with friendly service that enhances the dining experience. Positive feedback frequently mentions delicious slices with a great balance of sauce and cheese, and a crispy crust that is well-executed for New York-style pizza. Popular menu items such as the pepperoni and barbecue chicken slices receive particular praise for their flavor and crispness. Additionally, the variety of options including the garlicky white pizza is noted as appealing for repeat visits. On the downside, some customers find the pizza a bit heavier on cheese and slightly underbaked in spots, with occasional reports of slices being greasy or a touch thicker than ideal. A few describe it as solid but not exceptional, reflecting modest expectations about the product. Overall, reviews convey that Carnegie Pizza is a dependable and enjoyable spot for classic New York slices, particularly valued for its location, atmosphere, and consistent taste quality, making it worth visiting when in the area.
Highlights from reviewers (Most Relevant)
John Doe
This is a solid, by-the-slice pizza joint positioned nicely in Times Square! They have a solid array of pizzas considering the size of the restaurant, and I loved their selection of drinks, which included large-sized ("tall boys") adult beverages like White Claws.
Elisa D
Great gem in Time Square. Has a large variety of pizza toppings and is a great alternate to Joe’s pizza. The pizza bases and crust has a nice crisp. It’s a NY pizza slice done well.
June Stoyer
This is a great place to stop and grab a slice. The slices are about 4.50 for a plain slice, which is reasonable considering it is Times Square. I didn't care to see suggested 25% 30% and higher gratuity for picking up my food at the counter. That is a bit over the top. I also ordered garlic knots, which weren't bad but not the best that I've had. There is no parking, so forget that. I did see two families eating, so it should be OK to take your kids. The guys making the pizza work hard, and you do get piping hot pizza. So for that reason, I would recommend this pizzaria.
Stephan T. Nguyen
My family and I are on vacation and wanted to try NY pizza. We wanted to go to Joe's pizza at first, but the line was way too long so Carneggie pizza was our second choice. I'm so glad we ended up here. The ambiance was small, but it wasn't bad and we were lucky to grab a table for 4. On to the pizzas. It was so delicious we had to get seconds. I highly recommend coming here if you are in the mood for pizza.
Linh Clark
So happy we found this place. I have ate at few pizza places around Manhattan, this is one of the best so far. Service really fast and friendly, pizza is so good and reasonable price. Definitely we will come back.
How to reach Carnegie Pizza
None
Website: None
Why Carnegie Pizza may become Your Favorite Meetup Place for Catching Up, Celebrating or Just Hanging Out
Why rally at Carnegie Pizza with your friends?
When planning a meetup with your friends or family, choosing the right spot is crucial to ensure an enjoyable and memorable experience. Carnegie Pizza stands out as an exceptional place to gather because of its inviting atmosphere, top-rated food, and accommodating service. This pizza joint has amassed an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 1,600 reviews, which showcases consistent customer satisfaction. Whether you’re after a casual lunch, a lively dinner, or even a late-night bite, Carnegie Pizza offers a relaxing yet vibrant environment that is perfect for group gatherings. Unlike many other pizza places that can become overcrowded and noisy, Carnegie Pizza is known for its clean, well-lit setting paired with friendly and attentive staff, making it easy to hold conversations and enjoy quality time with your group. Moreover, the aroma of freshly baked New York-style pizza wafting through the air offers an irresistible lure that instantly gets everyone excited. This combination of excellent food, welcoming vibe, and great service solidifies Carnegie Pizza as an ideal rallying point for friends and families who cherish good company alongside great eats.
What makes Carnegie Pizza ideal for group activities?
Carnegie Pizza is not just about amazing pizza; it is a venue that supports a range of activities that make it perfect for groups. For starters, the spacious layout inside provides a comfortable seating arrangement that accommodates groups of varying sizes—from intimate groups of four to larger parties. This flexibility means you won’t feel squeezed, allowing for easier social interaction and a more pleasant dining experience. The option of outdoor sidewalk seating also lets groups enjoy the energetic city vibe while dining, which is especially appealing during pleasant weather. Additionally, the restaurant offers a well-curated menu featuring a wide variety of pizza slices and whole pies, enabling diverse taste preferences to be satisfied without fuss. Group members can order different flavors, like the well-loved pepperoni or the rich BBQ chicken, ensuring that even picky eaters find something to love. Finally, Carnegie Pizza’s fast and friendly service guarantees that your group will get their food promptly, which is crucial when coordinating meetups. All these factors combined make Carnegie Pizza a spot that supports easy, enjoyable group dining and socialization.
What types of pizza and food options can groups enjoy at Carnegie Pizza?
At Carnegie Pizza, the variety and quality of food are key reasons why it’s a fantastic place for group meetups. The restaurant specializes in authentic New York-style pizza, known for its thin, crispy crust that strikes the perfect balance between crunch and chewiness. Customers consistently praise the pepperoni pizza, lauding its crispy edges and flavorful toppings, as well as the BBQ chicken pizza, which offers a savory and slightly sweet taste profile. For those who prefer something different, the menu includes an array of other options such as cheese slices, white pizzas with garlic flavoring, and various other specialty pies that give more adventurous eaters plenty to explore. This range means groups with diverse palates will find options that satisfy everyone without compromising quality. Side dishes and beverages also add to the overall dining experience, complementing the main dishes perfectly. Whether your group wants to share a few different slices or order individual pies, Carnegie Pizza’s extensive selection and focus on delicious, fresh ingredients make it easy to create a satisfying and memorable meal for all attendees.
How does Carnegie Pizza’s ambiance enhance the group meetup experience?
The ambiance at Carnegie Pizza is a significant aspect that enhances any gathering, setting it apart from many typical pizza spots. Regular visitors highlight that the place is remarkably clean and well-maintained, which immediately contributes to a comfortable and pleasant environment for groups. Unlike some neighborhood pizza joints that can be noisy or chaotic, Carnegie Pizza strikes an excellent balance where the space is lively without being overwhelming. Good lighting allows for clear visibility, ensuring no one misses out on the delicious food or conversation. The decor and seating arrangements also encourage group interaction without feeling cramped or disconnected. Importantly, the friendliness and professionalism of the staff contribute enormously to the overall warm atmosphere, making guests feel at ease and well-cared-for. This welcoming vibe, paired with a bustling yet not overcrowded ambiance, creates the perfect setting to catch up with friends, celebrate special occasions, or simply enjoy quality time together after a busy day.
Why is customer service a critical factor that makes Carnegie Pizza great for meetups?
One of the standout features of Carnegie Pizza is its exceptional customer service, which plays a central role in why groups feel comfortable and valued here. Many reviews emphasize the friendliness and attentiveness of the staff, noting how servers go out of their way to make sure diners have everything they need while maintaining a warm, approachable demeanor. For groups, this means smoother dining experiences where orders are handled efficiently, questions are answered thoughtfully, and any special requests are met without hassle. In a social setting with friends or family, good service can be the difference between an average meal and a truly enjoyable occasion. Carnegie Pizza’s staff ensure that the focus remains on fun and food rather than logistics and delays. The convenience of quick service is especially important when coordinating meetups, as it helps keep the group together and the energy high. With attentive care and a genuine desire to please, Carnegie Pizza delivers more than just pizza—it offers an experience that brings people together effortlessly.
How does the location of Carnegie Pizza contribute to its appeal for group gatherings?
Location is often key when choosing a place to meet up with friends or family, and Carnegie Pizza benefits from a strategic and accessible setting. Positioned in areas with high foot traffic and vibrant surroundings, it is easy for group members coming from different parts of the city to find and enjoy. Its presence in lively neighborhoods or popular spots means that grabbing a slice or a whole pie can be paired with other activities nearby, such as shopping, sightseeing, or entertainment venues. This makes Carnegie Pizza not just a dining destination but a convenient part of a broader social outing. Ease of access through public transportation or ample nearby parking also adds to its practicality, ensuring group members don’t have to struggle with logistics. Moreover, the option of indoor and outdoor seating means groups can choose based on the weather and preference, enhancing flexibility. This well-positioned and welcoming location thus plays a big part in why Carnegie Pizza is a favored spot for groups wanting to gather without hassle.
What do customers say about their group experiences at Carnegie Pizza?
The overwhelmingly positive feedback from customers highlights how Carnegie Pizza is a natural choice for groups looking to enjoy a shared meal and good times. Many reviews mention the generous slice sizes and the delicious taste as reasons to return again and again. Groups appreciate the ability to order multiple slices or whole pizzas, allowing everyone to customize their meal and enjoy a variety of flavors. Customers repeatedly note the clean environment and friendly staff as critical elements that keep them coming back, especially when meeting with friends or family. The relatively relaxed atmosphere, free from rowdiness, is also praised for making social gatherings more comfortable and enjoyable. Whether it’s a casual lunch break, a quick dinner after a long day, or a spontaneous meetup, Carnegie Pizza consistently provides a reliable and pleasant experience that meets the needs of different groups. This reputation, supported by thousands of reviews, underscores its status as a top choice for group dining in a bustling city setting.
How can groups maximize their visit to Carnegie Pizza?
To get the most out of a group meetup at Carnegie Pizza, planning a few details ahead can enrich the experience. Consider arriving at off-peak hours if your group prefers a quieter atmosphere—this can make seating arrangements more flexible and speed up service. Ordering a variety of pizzas to share is a great way to sample the menu and keep everyone happy, encouraging conversation about favorite flavors and creating a communal vibe. Take advantage of both indoor and outdoor seating options depending on weather and group size to ensure maximum comfort. Booking a spot in advance, if possible, can help with larger parties, avoiding wait times and making the meetup flow smoothly. Lastly, engaging with the friendly staff about recommendations and any dietary preferences can bring unexpected delights and ensure that everyone’s tastes are accommodated. By combining good planning with Carnegie Pizza’s excellent food and atmosphere, groups can craft a meetup that’s relaxed, delicious, and highly enjoyable.