Why CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria is a fun option when searching for things to do near me with friends and family

CraigO's Pizza & Pastaria is a popular casual dining spot in Austin, Texas, celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza and homemade pasta dishes made from scratch. The cozy and informal atmosphere makes it an excellent place for friends to gather and enjoy hearty, satisfying meals together. Customers appreciate the generous portions, especially the large, foldable New York-style pizza slices topped with quality ingredients like large chunks of grilled white chicken and spicy meatballs. The restaurant's dedication to quality is evident in the crust, which boasts a crisp bottom with a good chew and excellent flavor, balancing well with the mozzarella cheese and subtly tangy sauce to create a classic, delicious pie. Beyond pizza, the menu offers a variety of Italian favorites, perfect for sharing or savoring individually. CraigO's is also family-friendly, featuring a patio with picturesque views of the hilly countryside and a playground area for children, making it ideal for casual get-togethers and relaxed meals. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, as well as reasonable prices, it stands out as a reliable and accessible choice for those craving quality Italian comfort food in a welcoming environment.

Here's what people think of CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria

As of recent, CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria holds a 4.5-star rating based on 385 reviews.

User reviews for CraigO's Pizza & Pastaria reflect a strong overall appreciation, as evidenced by the business's solid rating of 4.5 stars from 385 reviews. Patrons commonly praise the quality and taste of the New York-style pizza, particularly noting the crust's excellent flavor and texture, which is crispy yet chewy. Positive feedback highlights the generous toppings, especially the ample portions of grilled chicken and spicy meatballs, distinguishing CraigO's from other pizza places with scant toppings. The friendly, fast service and affordable pricing are frequently mentioned, contributing to the restaurant's reputation as a go-to pizza spot in Austin. The relaxed, informal atmosphere and family-friendly amenities like the outdoor patio and playground further enhance its appeal. However, some negative comments include occasional unavailability of signature items such as brownies and slight inconsistencies in topping choices leading to personal dissatisfaction. A few noted that the restaurant prioritizes simplicity over fanciness, which may not suit every diner’s expectations for ambiance. In summary, the reviews present CraigO's as a dependable option for those seeking authentic, flavorful New York-style pizza with hearty toppings, good value, and a welcoming atmosphere, while acknowledging minor areas for improvement in menu availability and ambiance.

Highlights from reviewers (Most Relevant)

D M

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The $1 Pizza rolls on Monday’s are dangerously good, and the staff treats you like family. Classic, local, and always satisfying. A must-visit for any pizza lover in ATX. Everything I have ever tried on the menu is delicious!

John Villalpando

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

CraigO's has been a time-tested favorite for my wife and I. Every time we go the atmosphere is always calm and the food is consistently delicious. Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo is my go-to favorite, personally.

Jordan Bevill

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I placed an order for two pizzas. The first was a medium white Italian with no red onions and replace them with black olives. The second was a large big kahuna without red onions and replace with green peppers. I didn’t open the boxes until I got home and they messed up the white Italian pizza. They did not replace the onions with black olives. The pizza was inedible for me so I called and they said they don’t do refunds but I could come back for a replacement. I was not going to drive across town for a pizza nor did I want store credit. I emailed the manager and I have yet to receive a response. I will not be going back here. The big kahuna was somehow undercooked but it had burnt crust. The quality was highly disappointing and I’ve had better pizza at CiCi’s. It also appears that they do not value customer service either. It was definitely not worth the $40 I paid for the two pizzas. I cannot not recommend this place to anyone until there have been significant changes within the establishment. It was the location on 11215 S. Order number OLO4 and it was placed approximately 5:45 on Jan 24.

Melissa Talbutt Gallegos

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Great first experience. Helpful, friendly staff. Delicious, hot food.

Miguel Fernando Asensio

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Greek pizza was better than average, but perhaps a touch too much cheese. Place is very clean.

How to reach CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria

Why rally at CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria with your friends?

Gathering your friends for a casual, flavorful dining experience finds its perfect match at CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria. Rated an impressive 4.5 out of 5 based on nearly 400 reviews, this local Austin gem is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a destination that encourages conviviality and shared enjoyment. The relaxed atmosphere and friendly staff create a welcoming space where groups of friends or family feel right at home, easily settling in for hours of conversation, laughter, and indulgence. At CraigO's, the focus on quality ingredients and hand-crafted dishes means your meal will always satisfy, whether you're craving a crispy New York-style pizza slice or hearty italian pastas. This reliable consistency paired with excellent service makes it an ideal spot for meetups where the food becomes a shared experience, sparking joy and bringing people closer. Plus, it's an affordable choice, letting everyone unwind without worrying about the bill. In essence, CraigO’s offers a compelling blend of great food, inviting environment, and genuine hospitality—everything you need to rally your friends for memorable moments.

What activities and group experiences make CraigO's perfect for meetups?

CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria tailors its entire dining experience to cater to groups looking for an easygoing yet satisfying outing. While the main attraction is undeniably the food, the restaurant fosters an atmosphere conducive to socializing. Groups can indulge in a variety of pizzas with diverse toppings, complementing each slice with fresh Greek salads or Italian pastas that suit every palate. The ordering style—counter service coupled with food brought directly to your table—allows flexibility and minimizes waiting time, so your group can stay engaged without interruption. This setup works well for casual celebrations, informal business meetups, or weekend hangouts, enabling easy conversation flow around shared plates. Additionally, the space’s layout supports grouping up comfortably, accommodating small to mid-sized gatherings without feeling cramped. The consistent positive feedback on staff friendliness adds to a seamless group experience, where hospitality helps you feel welcomed and looked after. While CraigO’s may not offer traditional entertainment facilities, the emphasis on excellent food and convivial environment serves as the perfect backdrop for creating lasting social memories.

How does the menu at CraigO's appeal to diverse tastes in a group?

One of CraigO's strongest assets when hosting a group meetup is its diverse menu, designed to appeal to a wide range of tastes and preferences. Pizza lovers appreciate the restaurant’s commitment to crafting authentic New York-style pizza, renowned for its thin, crisp crust with just the right balance of chew and a robust flavor profile. Toppings are generous and high-quality, including popular options like classic pepperoni as well as unique offerings such as sliced spicy meatballs that stand out as crowd-pleasers. For those looking for a lighter or alternative option, CraigO's offers fresh, well-prepared salads with authentic Mediterranean touches like the Greek salad, packed with crisp vegetables and tangy feta. Beyond pizza, the pastaria aspect means pasta enthusiasts can enjoy several Italian-inspired dishes that bring comforting, hearty flavors to the table. This range ensures that whether your group includes vegetarians, cheese lovers, or hearty eaters, everyone finds something satisfying. The homestyle preparation and scratch-made quality elevate the meal experience, making CraigO's a food-focused social hub that caters to different palates with ease.

What makes the atmosphere and service at CraigO's stand out for group gatherings?

Atmosphere and service provide the framework that transforms a dining venue into a memorable social space, and CraigO's excels in both. Frequent diners praise the friendly and attentive staff who not only maintain high service standards but also create a warm, neighborhood feel that invites repeat visits. This kind of hospitality matters when hosting groups, as efficient and personable service minimizes frustrations and keeps the energy positive. The environment is casual and unpretentious, avoiding the overwhelming noise or chaos sometimes found in larger restaurants, making it easier for groups to converse and enjoy each other’s company. Reviews consistently highlight how the staff’s genuine friendliness boosts the overall experience, creating an ambiance that feels more like a community gathering spot than just a place to eat. Even during busier times, the team works to maintain smooth operations and ensure all orders arrive promptly. For anyone planning a meetup with friends or family, this attentive service combined with a comfortable, inviting setting makes the venue stand apart as a reliably pleasing place to convene.

How does CraigO's value and location enhance the group meetup experience?

In addition to excellent food and service, CraigO's value proposition and convenient location significantly enhance its appeal as a gathering spot. With modest prices across pizzas, pastas, and salads, the restaurant makes hosting groups affordable, eliminating the pressure for guests to overspend. This accessibility encourages larger turnout and repeated meetups, as guests can indulge without hesitation. The restaurant’s location in Austin, near popular landmarks and neighborhood hubs, further increases its attractiveness as a meetup spot. Easy parking and proximity to other entertainment or social venues allow groups to combine dining with other activities such as sightseeing or after-dinner drinks nearby. The familiar, local vibe of CraigO’s also helps groups feel connected to the Austin community, adding a dimension of shared local pride to the experience. All these factors combined mean that planning your next friends or family gathering at CraigO’s is logistically simple, financially smart, and socially rewarding.

What makes CraigO's a reliable choice for repeat group visits?

Many reviewers emphasize not just their initial satisfaction but their willingness to return to CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria time and again. This speaks to the consistency in food quality, service, and atmosphere that CraigO’s maintains—critical considerations when hosting recurrent social meetups. Basic comforts such as freshly made dough, carefully balanced ingredients, and steady attention from staff ensure that every visit meets high expectations. This reliability offers peace of mind when organizing group outings, eradicates worries over disappointing guests with subpar food or service, and helps build a tradition of gathering at a trusted favorite place. The variety of menu options and accommodating environment mean groups can revisit with confidence that both new and familiar faces will enjoy their experience. This consistent excellence, combined with the inviting community feel, transforms CraigO’s Pizza and Pastaria into more than just a restaurant—it becomes a dependable cornerstone for social connection and shared enjoyment in Austin.

Why is CraigO's considered more than just a pizza place?

While pizza is certainly the star at CraigO's, the restaurant prides itself on offering a complete Italian dining experience that extends beyond the slice. Many reviews underline its status as a solid Italian food restaurant, emphasizing quality pastas and fresh salads alongside the well-crafted pizzas. This diversity makes it an appealing venue for groups with varied tastes or dietary needs. The Italian influence permeates the menu and ambiance, giving guests a sense of authenticity and careful culinary tradition. Whether you're indulging in a cheesy, perfectly browned pizza slice or savoring a steaming bowl of pasta, the care in preparation speaks through. This sophisticated yet approachable Italian focus means your group can enjoy a well-rounded meal experience, avoiding the limitations often associated with pizzerias. In this way, CraigO’s serves as a vibrant neighborhood hub that brings a touch of Italy to Austin, perfect for social dining that feels a bit special.

With its 4.5-star rating from 385 reviews, CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria proves to be an outstanding venue for meetups. It offers a warm and inviting setting, menu variety for all tastes, attentive service, and good value—all critical ingredients for a successful group gathering. Whether it's a casual hangout, birthday celebration, or family reunion, CraigO's blends the best of quality food and convivial atmosphere to make every meet memorable and worth repeating.

Don't just take our word for it. Check out these other websites for more info on the CraigO's Pizza and Pastaria

• https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g30196-d5889798-Reviews-CraigO_s_Pizza_Pastaria-Austin_Texas.html
• https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g56130-d2431468-Reviews-CraigO_s_Pizza_Pastaria_Lakeway-Lakeway_Texas.html
• https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g30196-d437929-Reviews-CraigO_s_Pizza_Pastaria-Austin_Texas.html