When asking yourself about something to do near me in San Diego with a group of friends or family, consider
Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison
Why Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison is a fun option when searching for things to do near me with friends and family
Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison is a standout Mexican-fusion restaurant located in the vibrant Barrio Logan neighborhood of San Diego. This restaurant mesmerizes guests with its unique blend of Mexican, Tex-Mex, and Latin American flavors, creating a culinary journey that is both authentic and innovative. The kitchen acts as a 'cauldron of creativity,' where chefs conjure dishes that balance bold spices, fresh ingredients, and artistic presentation, making each plate a masterpiece to delight the senses. Alchemy offers both indoor and outdoor seating, with a gothic-industrial ambiance indoors and a larger outdoor patio illuminated by curated art and gas lamps, providing a charming and intimate setting for friends to gather. Open for lunch, dinner, and weekend brunch, it caters to various dining preferences with distinct offerings like seafood, punch bowls, and craft libations. The staff’s dedication to personalized service and the restaurant’s evolving creativity ensure an enchanting and memorable experience, ideal for meeting up with friends to savor outstanding food, drinks, and atmosphere.
Here's what people think of Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison
As of recent, Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison holds a 5-star rating based on 96 reviews.
With a perfect 5.0 rating based on 96 reviews, Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison is highly regarded by diners. Reviewers consistently praise the restaurant for its exceptional fusion cuisine that masterfully blends Mexican and Latin American flavors, highlighting the freshness and flavorful complexity of the dishes. Positive feedback commonly mentions the restaurant's inviting ambiance, where the combination of art, lighting, and thoughtful design enhances the overall dining experience. Many appreciate the attentive and friendly service, making guests feel valued and welcome. The creative cocktail program and punch bowls are also notable favorites among patrons. On the other hand, some negative remarks focus on the limited indoor seating capacity, which can make the restaurant feel busy or crowded during peak times. A few guests noted the absence of a full liquor license initially, though the establishment is working toward expanding its beverage offerings. Despite minor critiques, the broad consensus is that Alchemy offers a unique and delightful culinary experience. Overall, reviews reflect that Alchemy delivers on its promise of a magical, flavorful journey, making it a must-visit spot in San Diego’s dining scene.
Highlights from reviewers (Most Relevant)
J H
We made a dinner reservation for 8 for our friend’s birthday party. Did the tasting menu 4 course paired with cocktails. Absolutely amazing experience. Owner/ chef Eddie did fantastic job with the food and drinks. Everything was very flavorful, rich and great portions. Our group liked every dish that came out with no complaints. We will definitely be back. If you are debating on going I would say book your reservation now before they begin to get busier.
Luna Bello Reis
A hidden gem worth every bite. Alchemy is the kind of place you want to gatekeep—but it’s just too good not to share. Tucked away in an intimate space that seats maybe 16 people, this cozy little spot delivers some of the best food and atmosphere I’ve experienced in a long time. The braised rib? Absolutely to die for. Melt-in-your-mouth perfection that I’m still thinking about. This isn’t one of those trendy “Instagram-only” restaurants—it’s the real deal. Every dish is crafted with care, and you can taste the difference. The owner himself was our server, and his passion for what he does shines through in the exceptional service. Warm, welcoming, and genuinely attentive. And don’t even get me started on the happy hour—it’s hands down the best in town. Support this hidden gem so it sticks around, but go soon… once people find out, it’s going to be impossible to get a seat!
Gabriela Noelle Zappia
Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison absolutely blew us away! Came here with two friends to celebrate a promotion and everything exceeded our expectations. The shrimp zarandeado was phenomenal - easily my favorite dish of the night, though honestly everything we tried was delicious. The menu is unique and refreshing for San Diego. Whether you're visiting or a local — you really should experience it. The cocktail menu is outstanding! We sampled the bone smoke, elixir of life, and bloodstone - all were expertly crafted and unique. You can tell there's real artistry behind the bar. What really sets this place apart is the beautiful ambiance - it's truly special for San Diego and creates such a memorable atmosphere. Perfect for special occasions, dining with friends, or a romantic date night. All that said the star is the service! The entire staff is genuinely passionate about what they're serving, and their enthusiasm is infectious. They clearly love sharing this incredible food and experience with guests. Special shoutout to Alex, our server, who provided such exceptional service! This is the kind of place that makes you excited about San Diego's dining scene. Alchemy has truly mastered the art of combining incredible food, drinks, and atmosphere. Can't wait to come back!
Debbie Chialtas
Looking for an intimate date night restaurant that makes you feel like you’ve been transported to a new city? Alchemy is for you. Located in Barrio Logan, this very small, artistic bistro is unpretentious yet elegant. From the moment you walk up to the building, you’ll be surprised at every turn. When you get there, you’ll know what I mean! It feels like a well guarded secret. The atmosphere is eclectic and intimate. The menu is small yet full of tempting dishes, all pulling from the chef’s Mexico City roots. The cocktail menu is equally creative and definitely delivers in flavors and aesthetics. The majority of the entrees are gluten free (yay!) and there are vegan options, too. Reservations are available and you might get lucky if you’re looking for a last minute date night. We were able to get one the night of. We just loved Alchemy and we’ll be back!
Anna Belous
Recently revisited Alchemy Choose Thy Poison and it was somehow even better than last time! This experience is unlike any other in San Diego being completely outside nestled into a hotel complex. The cocktails are super fun and creative, and the dishes are contemporary bites straight from Mexico City. I always recommend the Albondigas smash burger, one of the best burgers you'll have in San Diego. The shrimp zarandeado have perfectly grilled shrimp with an amazing sauce! I appreciate that while they have a small menu it has a lot of variety (lamb, beef, shrimp, fish, veggies,cetc)
How to reach Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison
None
Website: None
Why Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison may become Your Favorite Meetup Place for Catching Up, Celebrating or Just Hanging Out
Why rally at Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison with your friends?
Gathering your friends at Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison is an excellent choice because it offers more than just a meal—it's a complete experiential adventure in the heart of San Diego's vibrant dining scene. With a stellar 5.0 rating from 96 reviews, this Mexican-fusion restaurant has earned widespread acclaim for its exceptional food, inviting atmosphere, and outstanding service. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply want to enjoy an evening out with your closest circle, Alchemy provides a captivating setting that encourages socializing and engagement. The menu is designed to share, which perfectly aligns with group dining—allowing you and your friends to sample a variety of creative and flavorful dishes together. The combination of unique, artfully crafted cocktails and a warm, beautifully decorated environment creates a dynamic vibe suited for lively conversations and memorable moments. In addition, the staff’s friendly and attentive service guarantees that your group feels cared for and comfortable throughout your visit. This mix of culinary excellence, ambiance, and hospitality makes Alchemy an ideal rallying point when you want your gathering to resonate beyond just a typical meal.
What kinds of activities does Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison offer that make it ideal for group meetups?
Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison is designed to facilitate social interaction and group enjoyment, offering multiple engaging experiences that go beyond traditional dining. First and foremost, their menu is structured to encourage sharing—dishes are crafted with bold Mexican-fusion flavors that complement each other perfectly when ordered in variety. This allows groups to embark on a culinary journey together, tasting everything from classic staples to inventive fusion plates that surprise the palate. Alongside food, their cocktail program is a highlight, featuring imaginative drinks that invite guests to “choose thy poison” — an experience that combines mixology with theatrical presentation. This encourages conversation starters and fun, interactive drinking moments for groups. Additionally, the restaurant hosts a well-curated brunch, lunch, and dinner service, so your group can choose the perfect time to gather, whether for a casual weekend brunch or a sophisticated evening outing. Their team also promotes group bookings and catering services, tailoring the event experience to fit your group’s exact needs. The ambiance, complete with artistic decor and mood lighting, further enhances your group’s enjoyment by creating a comfortable yet distinctive atmosphere that sparks connection and celebration.
Why is Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison especially suitable for hosting a party or special event?
When it comes to hosting parties or special celebrations, Alchemy stands out thanks to its commitment to personalized service and atmosphere. The establishment offers group and party bookings, which means your event can be customized to your tastes and requirements—from menu selection to seating arrangements. This bespoke approach ensures that every detail aligns with your vision, providing an intimate yet lively environment that makes each guest feel valued. The staff’s attentiveness and professionalism mean you and your friends won’t have to worry about logistics or service—they focus solely on making your celebration seamless and memorable. The restaurant’s beautiful interior, complemented by mood lighting and tasteful decor, establishes a stylish backdrop ideal for photos and lasting memories. Furthermore, the extensive menu of Mexican-fusion cuisine paired with inventive cocktails means your party will enjoy a unique culinary experience that stands out from typical event venues. Whether it’s a birthday, reunion, or casual group gathering, Alchemy creates an exclusive yet relaxed space that transforms your event into a true celebration of friendship and good taste.
What is the food and drink experience like at Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison?
Dining at Alchemy is a journey through rich Mexican flavors with a modern fusion twist, perfect for adventurous food lovers and groups eager to explore diverse tastes together. The menu features both traditional and innovative dishes, made with fresh and quality ingredients crafted into vibrant, complex flavors. Many customers emphasize the joy of sharing multiple dishes—this not only allows a variety of tastes at the table but also enhances the communal experience of dining. Signature items such as Aguachile Negro and Tetelas stand out as flavor-packed highlights, praised for their authenticity and creativity. Complementing the food is an imaginative cocktail menu, well-regarded for extraordinary concoctions that pair perfectly with the meals. These drinks often serve as conversation pieces and add a playful vibe to the dining experience. Coupled with the beautifully arranged plates and presentation, every visit feels like a curated celebration of culinary art. The delicious, flavorful combination of food and drinks is what keeps guests coming back and makes Alchemy a favorite spot for social evenings and special occasions.
How does the ambiance and service at Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison elevate the group experience?
The ambiance at Alchemy is one of its most distinctive features, blending artistic decor, warm lighting, and a welcoming layout to create an atmosphere that feels both elegant and inviting. Whether you’re seated indoors or in the outdoor patio area, the environment encourages relaxed and engaging gatherings where conversation flows easily. The restaurant’s design intriguingly complements its theme of alchemy and transformation, enhancing the overall sensory experience beyond just taste. Service at Alchemy is consistently praised for friendliness and attentiveness, ensuring that groups—often diverse in size and preference—are effectively accommodated. Staff members are knowledgeable about the menu and cocktails, offering helpful guidance and recommendations to enhance your meal. This thoughtful, personalized service allows groups to focus fully on their social interaction without concerns about timing, ordering, or comfort. The combination of mood-setting ambiance and superb service makes every gathering feel special and enjoyable, whether you’re catching up with close friends or celebrating with family.
What makes Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison stand out in San Diego’s competitive dining scene?
Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison distinguishes itself through its unique blend of Mexican-fusion cuisine, immersive thematic design, and an elevated bar experience—offering something fresh and different in San Diego’s bustling food landscape. Amid many Mexican or fusion restaurants, Alchemy’s commitment to exceptional quality, creative dishes, and detailed presentation sets a higher standard that resonates strongly with food enthusiasts and casual diners alike. Its consistently perfect 5.0-star rating from nearly a hundred reviews reflects a level of excellence in both food and service that few establishments achieve. It’s not only a place to eat but a destination where culinary art meets a social atmosphere, making it a preferred spot for those who want to combine sophistication with fun. By fostering an environment that prioritizes group experiences—be it through shareable dishes, cocktail adventures, or private event accommodations—Alchemy successfully meets the needs of modern diners looking for more than just a meal. This innovative approach ensures that every visit feels like a special occasion, reinforcing its reputation as a must-visit venue in San Diego.
How easy is it to book or plan a group outing at Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison?
Planning your group outing at Alchemy is straightforward and designed to be flexible. The restaurant actively encourages reservations and group bookings to ensure space and service are optimized for your party size. Whether you’re planning a small intimate dinner or a larger celebratory event, Alchemy’s team is available to work with you on tailoring the experience to your group’s specific wishes—including menu customization and seating configurations. Their catering services also extend their hospitality offsite, allowing you to bring the unique Alchemy vibe to your private event locations. Online booking options and responsive staff make the reservation process hassle-free, while the restaurant’s central San Diego location offers easy access for locals and visitors alike. This convenience paired with the restaurant’s readiness to accommodate special requests makes it an ideal pick for groups who seek both quality and flexibility in event planning.
Why do guests keep coming back to Alchemy - Choose Thy Poison?
Guests return to Alchemy not just for the food but for the complete experiential package the establishment offers. Reviewers consistently highlight the harmonious blend of innovative, delicious food and expertly crafted cocktails that surprise and satisfy. Beyond the menu, its engaging ambiance and attentive service create a welcoming environment where every visit feels personalized and memorable. The ability to share plates encourages a sense of community and connection among friends and family, making dining here feel like a celebration. Many also appreciate the range of service hours, including brunch and dinner options, offering versatility in planning casual or special meals. Positive word-of-mouth and glowing online reviews further fuel repeat visits, affirming the restaurant’s standing as a beloved spot in the San Diego culinary community. Ultimately, Alchemy’s dedication to quality, creativity, and guest experience builds lasting relationships with diners who consistently choose it as their go-to gathering place.