When asking yourself about something to do near me in New York with a group of friends or family, consider
Highline Pizzeria
Why Highline Pizzeria is a fun option when searching for things to do near me with friends and family
Highline Pizzeria, located at 503 W 28th St in New York City, has become a known locale for pizza lovers looking for a casual and quick bite near the High Line park. This pizzeria offers a distinctive New York-style slice characterized by a crunchy crust and a notably light application of sauce, making it stand out from other pizzerias in the area. Although the establishment is relatively small with only four stools for seating, it provides a cozy spot to enjoy freshly made pizza along with cold drinks. Highline Pizzeria is praised for its cheese quality and the floppiness of its slices, which delivers a classic but slightly different pizza experience. Its convenient location, just steps from the High Line, makes it an ideal meet-up spot for friends exploring the area or those wanting a quick and satisfying meal. With a menu that has recently been expanded, patrons can expect a variety of items beyond pizza, adding to the venue's appeal as a casual gathering point in the Chelsea neighborhood.
Here's what people think of Highline Pizzeria
As of recent, Highline Pizzeria holds a 4.3-star rating based on 911 reviews.
Based on 911 reviews with an average rating of 4.3, Highline Pizzeria has received mixed feedback from customers. Positive reviews often highlight the high-quality cheese, the deliciously crunchy crust, and the quick service as key strengths. Many enjoy the pizza’s light sauce, which lets the cheese and crust flavors shine, and the overall authentic New York pizza vibe. Additionally, some customers appreciate the pizzeria’s location near the High Line and the casual atmosphere, making it a convenient and pleasant place to meet up with friends for a quick snack. On the other hand, negative reviews point out issues such as slices being overly cheesy to the point of lacking balance, the sauce being almost absent in some cases, and occasional problems with other menu items like the chicken parm hero being overcooked or burnt. Some critiques also mention inconsistencies in pizza quality and a few instances of the pizza being greasy or not up to expectation. Despite these drawbacks, Highline Pizzeria remains a popular spot, especially among those who value a simple, no-frills New York slice experience. Overall, the pizzeria’s strengths in crust and cheese quality, combined with its convenient location, help maintain a solid fan base despite some critics.
Highlights from reviewers (Most Relevant)
Patrick Zajac
Got the chicken bacon slice and the flavor and crust were on point. Little more bacon leaning than chicken but the crust was so crunchy and perfect. I thought that this slice was going to have a white sauce but I don’t think it had a sauce at all because it was pretty dry.
Jordan Gonzales
Highline Pizzeria is back, and it’s better than ever! This gem in Chelsea just reopened, and you can feel the love the new (original owners) put into every pie. I had the classic pepperoni, and the crust was perfection—thin, crispy, and just the right amount of chew. The sauce is fresh, and the cheese is perfectly melted. The new owners have turned this place around, creating a warm, welcoming spot for locals and visitors alike. If you’re craving authentic NY pizza, Highline Pizzeria on 28th St is a must-visit.
Ziad Awartani
This is a small shop for carryout or eat outside. The pizza is amazing. $6 a slice. 10/10 recommend. They are open as of 7/5/2025
Aunt Judy
Hands down the best pizza I’ve had in NYC—and I’ve lived here for 21 years! The cheese was incredibly flavorful, and the crust was absolutely perfect. I brought my 19 yr old niece and her boyfriend and they Loved it! It's in a prime spot right off the High Line at 23rd Street, with convenient steps leading straight to it. We called 15 minutes ahead, and our order was ready and waiting when we arrived. Excellent service and even better pizza!
G Lee
Pretty good pizza, especially for this part of town where pizza parlors are scarce. About $5 on average per slice. Cheese is on par with Joe’s, I think. But the chicken parm was pretty damn good. Love the crispy crust from the ‘re-bake’. And they have some seats out front (none inside).
How to reach Highline Pizzeria
None
Website: None
Why Highline Pizzeria may become Your Favorite Meetup Place for Catching Up, Celebrating or Just Hanging Out
Why rally at this place with your friends?
Highline Pizzeria is an ideal spot to gather with friends because it offers a unique combination of delicious, authentic New York-style pizza, friendly service, and a convenient location right off the High Line, one of Manhattan’s most popular walkways. The welcoming atmosphere and fast, attentive staff make it easy to relax and chat while enjoying some of the best slices in the city. Groups appreciate the pizzeria’s accommodating nature, with the owner personally ensuring even large parties feel well taken care of. Whether you’re looking to grab a quick slice during a city stroll or hold a casual meetup with friends over hearty pies, Highline Pizzeria creates an inviting environment that blends quality food with a social vibe. Its off-the-beaten-path location means you can enjoy a nice break from the usual crowded spots while savoring great flavor, making it a memorable place to connect. Authenticity and warmth converge here, which is why friends find themselves rallying at Highline to share food and good times after exploring the nearby High Line park.
What activities can you enjoy at Highline Pizzeria for group meetups?
Highline Pizzeria primarily serves as a fantastic casual dining destination where groups can enjoy delicious pizza together, but the experience extends beyond just eating. The pizzeria’s small but cozy indoor seating with a few stools allows friends or family to sit and chat comfortably. Since it is located steps away from the High Line park, many groups combine a leisurely walk along the elevated green space with a pizza break. This makes for an activity-rich hangout: start with scenic views and urban exploration, then indulge in satisfying eats. The staff’s friendly engagement adds an element of warmth to the visit, with owner Scott notably going above and beyond to accommodate large groups, even delivering pizzas directly to the High Line itself for an outdoor picnic-style meetup. For those who want a quick, tasty stop, grabbing slices to go and gathering nearby is common, creating a lively social scene. The fresh, crunchy crust and well-balanced flavors make every bite conversationally enjoyable, promoting a relaxed, communal vibe perfect for any group dynamic.
Why is Highline Pizzeria perfect for hosting meetups with friends or family?
Highline Pizzeria’s combination of quality pizza, attentive service, and its unique location make it an excellent choice for group meetups. The 4.3-star rating from over 900 reviews highlights a strong customer appreciation for both the food and atmosphere, reassuring visitors that their experience will be satisfying. The staff’s effort to provide personalized service—such as managing very large groups and facilitating outdoor enjoyment—shows a level of hospitality that helps meetups run smoothly. Even with limited indoor seating, the pizzeria encourages socializing by enabling guests to take their food to nearby seating areas outside or onto the High Line itself, integrating the natural surroundings with the urban dining experience. The menu includes fan favorites like chicken parm pizza slices, which have been praised for their flavor and generosity. This mix of excellent pizza, a great setting near a popular park, and a service culture that cares deeply about group experiences makes Highline Pizzeria a natural gathering place for friends and families looking to share memorable moments over classic New York pizza.
How does the location of Highline Pizzeria enhance your group meetup experience?
The location of Highline Pizzeria at 503 W 28th St in New York City is key to its appeal for group meetups. Nestled just off the High Line, a beautifully landscaped elevated park stretching through Chelsea and the Meatpacking District, it allows visitors to combine outdoor enjoyment with casual dining seamlessly. Groups can start their meetups with a refreshing stroll along the High Line with its striking city views and public art, then stop in for a slice or two without needing to stray far. This proximity means guests can eat either inside on the four available stools or outside in nearby seating areas that facilitate socializing in the fresh air. The vibrant neighborhood atmosphere adds to the experience, offering a blend of urban energy and laid-back charm. Whether for casual catch-ups, family outings, or post-High Line picnics, the location supports diverse ways to socialize. It enhances convenience, as groups can easily move between walking, eating, and relaxing, creating a fluid, enjoyable meetup in one of NYC’s trendiest areas.
What makes the food at Highline Pizzeria a crowd-pleaser for groups?
The food at Highline Pizzeria wins over crowds due to its authentic New York style, fresh ingredients, and balanced flavor profile. The pizzas feature a crunchy crust paired with a lighter application of sauce, a characteristic that appeals to those who prefer the classic slice without heaviness. Cheese is generously but thoughtfully applied, contributing to a satisfying but not overwhelming eating experience. Among the highly recommended options is the chicken parm slice, noted for having bold, rich flavors that stand out even against the competition in NYC’s pizza scene. Such specialty slices offer a great way to share unique tastes within a group. While some reviews mention that the sauce is lighter than some prefer, most find the toppings and crust quality exceptional enough to please a variety of palates. Additionally, the speedy, friendly service ensures hot, fresh slices come quickly, maintaining the communal vibe essential to group outings. The combination of quality and consistency makes the food ideal for bonding over comfort eats.
How does the service at Highline Pizzeria contribute to a memorable group experience?
Service at Highline Pizzeria is frequently highlighted by visitors as a major factor that enhances the overall experience, especially for groups. The staff are described as genuinely friendly and attentive, creating an inviting atmosphere where guests feel like valued friends rather than just customers. Owner Scott, in particular, garners praise for his dedication to customer satisfaction, famously accommodating a party of 40 by personally delivering pizza to the High Line to ensure a unique outdoor gathering experience. This level of care goes beyond typical pizzeria service and fosters a welcoming environment where groups can relax and enjoy their time together without logistical hassles. Fast service keeps food coming promptly, avoiding long wait times that can dampen social gatherings. The staff's accommodating nature and genuine smiles encourage casual conversation, making the venue feel more like a community hub suited for group celebrations or casual meetups. Excellent service ensures that hosting friends or family here feels effortless and enjoyable.
What options exist for seating and atmosphere that support group gatherings at Highline Pizzeria?
Though Highline Pizzeria is a relatively small establishment with only four stools inside, the seating and atmosphere complement group gatherings through versatility and outdoor integration. The limited indoor space creates an intimate, casual setting where friends can sit closely and chat over their slices; it’s perfect for smaller groups who want an immersive pizzeria vibe. However, the real strength lies in the flexibility to take food outside. Highline’s proximity to the High Line park means guests can easily carry their pizzas to nearby benches or green spaces for a more expansive meetup. This open-air option is especially attractive during pleasant weather and encourages relaxed, picnic-style socializing. Additionally, there is some outdoor seating in the immediate vicinity of the pizzeria, providing another place for casual dining outside the often-bustling indoor space. This combination of indoor coziness and outdoor freedom supports a variety of group sizes and preferences, making it easy to tailor the meetup experience to the day’s mood or group dynamic.
What are some common reasons visitors recommend Highline Pizzeria for group meetups?
Visitors consistently recommend Highline Pizzeria for group meetups due to its winning blend of great food, excellent service, and ideal location. Reviewers often note how the slices are "fantastic," with crunchy crusts and well-balanced toppings, making it a satisfying choice for sharing. The ability to enjoy pizza near the High Line with friends while experiencing one of NYC’s most iconic urban parks adds a unique dimension to the meetup. Many praise the staff for going the extra mile to accommodate large groups — from quick service to personalized attention and even pizza delivery directly onto the High Line. This demonstrates a commitment to making group outings hassle-free and memorable. The atmosphere is relaxed but vibrant, and the menu includes crowd-pleasing classics that suit various tastes. Whether for a quick snack or an extended hangout, visitors feel confident recommending Highline Pizzeria as a friendly, flavorful, and fun place to gather with friends or family.
How can groups make the most of a visit to Highline Pizzeria?
Groups visiting Highline Pizzeria can maximize their experience by planning around both the pizzeria’s offerings and its unique setting. Arriving after a walk along the High Line allows everyone to work up an appetite and take in beautiful city views before settling down to a pizza feast. Ordering a mix of classic slices and specialty options like the chicken parm slice encourages shared tasting and conversation. Taking advantage of the friendly service by asking for recommendations or group accommodations can enhance the visit. If the weather is good, choosing to eat outside or have the pizzas delivered to the nearby park makes the meetup more dynamic and memorable. Bringing along blankets to spread out on the grass or benches at the High Line can create a picnic ambiance. Sharing food fosters a communal vibe, and lingering to chat in the park afterwards makes the visit a full experience beyond just dining. Planning to meet during quieter hours may improve seating availability and the overall feel, ensuring a smooth, enjoyable gathering.
What distinguishes Highline Pizzeria from other pizza places in New York City as a meetup spot?
Highline Pizzeria stands out from other NYC pizza places because of its strategic location right near the High Line, its commitment to customer experience, and its reputation for consistently good pizza that balances tradition with innovation. Unlike typical pizza joints packed with tourists, it offers a more relaxed, off-the-beaten-path vibe while still delivering authentic New York slices. The owner’s personal involvement in serving large groups and innovative touch such as delivering pizza directly to guests on the High Line elevate the experience and reflect a level of care uncommon in fast-food pizza places. Additionally, its combination of crunchy crust, lighter sauce, and quality cheese strikes a satisfying balance that many pizza lovers appreciate. The pizzeria's integration with the surrounding urban park creates a unique social and scenic context that few competitors can match. This blend of food, service, and location makes it an exceptional choice for those wanting a genuine, enjoyable setting to host meetups with friends or family in the heart of NYC.