When asking yourself about something to do near me in New York with a group of friends or family, consider
Made In New York Pizza
Why Made In New York Pizza is a fun option when searching for things to do near me with friends and family
Made In New York Pizza, located on the Upper West Side at 421 Amsterdam Avenue, offers an inviting atmosphere ideal for meeting up with friends who share a love for classic New York-style pizza. The pizzeria is especially known for its distinctive square pepperoni slice, which boasts crispy pepperoni cups and a crunchy crust, providing a delightful textural contrast that has won loyal fans. Besides the signature square slices, the menu includes a variety of options such as a square white slice and an upside-down slice with a notably sweet tomato sauce, catering to diverse palates. The presence of numerous tables makes it convenient for groups to dine in comfortably, but it’s equally popular for takeout. Its location and reliable quality make it a cherished local spot to gather, enjoy hearty pizza slices, and share good times in a casual, friendly setting. Whether it's a casual lunch, a quick bite after work, or a weekend meal with friends, Made In New York Pizza offers a classic New York pizzeria experience with a few creative touches that set it apart on the Upper West Side.
Here's what people think of Made In New York Pizza
As of recent, Made In New York Pizza holds a 4.6-star rating based on 1143 reviews.
Customer reviews highlight Made In New York Pizza's consistent quality and unique appeal. Users particularly praise the square pepperoni slice for its crispy cups and well-balanced sauce, describing the crust as excellently crunchy and the toppings flavorful, which makes it a standout on the Upper West Side. Positive feedback also notes the hospitality of the staff, who sometimes recommend their favorite slices, enhancing the overall dining experience and making patrons feel welcome. Many appreciate the affordability and safety of their gluten-free options, along with thoughtful measures like providing a personal pizza cutter to avoid cross-contamination.
However, some negative reviews mention that the pizza can be a bit greasy, which may be off-putting for those sensitive to heavier slices. A few customers found the crust underwhelming, labeling it as somewhat dry or cracker-like, and mentioned inconsistent cooking times, particularly for gluten-free pizzas, which occasionally led to wait times or dissatisfaction. There are also occasional remarks about the staff being less friendly or responsive.
Overall, the reviews suggest that while Made In New York Pizza excels in delivering flavorful and iconic New York-style slices, there is room for improvement in consistency and customer service. Nonetheless, the pizzeria remains a highly rated and well-loved spot, offering robust flavors and an authentic local experience that many find worth returning to time and again.
Highlights from reviewers (Most Relevant)
George Koshy
Quick and fast service and yet fresh and as amazing as it can get. The perfect place to experience as the name itself suggests the perfect new York pizza. An amazing variety of things crust and deep dish, veg and non veg options here to pair with a whole bunch of sodas in stock. Loads of internal seating and the outside ones come alive with the weather too!
Naaz Khan
Honestly, I’ve had better pizza. Since I’m a red sauce pizza person, I went for the Burrata pizza and the Upside Down pizza both heavy on the sauce. But the sauce leaned way too sweet for my taste. Definitely not one of NYC’s best pizza spots.
Chase E
So many great options for pizza slices and they all were very delicious! Staff is kind and very quick and efficient and the outdoor seating on the streets of Manhattan is great for any visitor, this is definitely my recommendation for pizza slices in NYC.
Urban Lyphstyle
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 Hands down, the BEST New York-style pizza I’ve had in a long time! “Made in New York Pizza” delivers everything you’d want in an authentic NYC slice—crispy, thin crust with that perfect fold, rich and flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. The dough tastes fresh, the toppings are top quality, and you can tell they take real pride in every pie they make. The atmosphere has that classic, no-frills NYC pizzeria vibe—quick, friendly service, clean space, and the smell alone is enough to make your mouth water the second you walk in. I grabbed a pepperoni and a white slice, and both were absolutely 🔥🔥🔥. Whether you’re a tourist wanting the real NYC pizza experience or a local looking for your go-to spot, this place is a must-visit. Trust me, one slice won’t be enough. Can’t wait to come back! 📸 As someone who runs a creative agency focused on photography, videography, and marketing, I can say this spot is photogenic and flavorful. If you’re a restaurant looking to level up your online presence, highlight your menu with mouth-watering visuals, or capture the soul of your brand on video — I’d love to collaborate! DM me or visit my page to see how we can make your food and business stand out in a crowded digital world. 🍕🎥📱
Danny K
I have been to another branch of this place a bunch of times and always found the pizza to be quite decent. But a few years ago I stopped eating dairy and since they have no interest in making nondairy pizza (I once asked, and the response I got was a hard no), I stopped going. But tonight I wanted a slice and it was the only place that was open so I went for it. I ordered a margarita and, while the taste was consistent with the quality of pizza I’ve had from them before, I was surprised at how much crust there was, what one other reviewer called “a ton of crust.“ I don’t think I’ve ever gotten a slice that was 30% crust (see photo). If quality is a concern, I don’t think they should sell slices like this one and maybe I should’ve spoken up, but whatever. If I’m going to pay $5.50 for a slice, I would like one that comes with a proper amount of cheese and sauce, and not one in which so much of the real estate of the surface of the slice is just crust.
How to reach Made In New York Pizza
None
Website: None
Why Made In New York Pizza may become Your Favorite Meetup Place for Catching Up, Celebrating or Just Hanging Out
Why rally at Made In New York Pizza with your friends?
Gathering friends at Made In New York Pizza is an ideal way to share delicious food and memorable moments. This pizzeria offers authentic New York–style pizza with a reputation for crispy crusts, fresh natural ingredients, and high-quality cheeses that capture the essence of classic NYC pizza culture. The friendly, casual atmosphere makes it an inviting spot for groups looking to enjoy a relaxed, tasty meal without pretense or fuss. Whether you and your friends crave a cheesy pepperoni slice with crispy cups or a unique square white slice with sweet tomato sauce, this place delivers consistently excellent flavors that have earned it a strong 4.6-star rating from over a thousand reviews. The flexible seating option allows your group to linger and savor your slices together or grab quick takeout for adventures elsewhere. Made In New York Pizza blends the charm of authentic New York cuisine with an accessible neighborhood vibe, making it a perfect place to celebrate friendship and good times over iconic pizza.
What activities can you do at Made In New York Pizza as a group meetup?
Made In New York Pizza is primarily a culinary hotspot, but that doesn’t limit the social activities you can enjoy during your meetup. First and foremost, sharing a variety of pizza slices encourages conversation and lively exchanges about favorite toppings or the best New York pizza style—critical when you have a group with diverse tastes. The spacious seating arrangements offer a setting suited for casual dining as well as small celebrations or birthday gatherings, making it easy to linger and chat. Near the Upper West Side location, you can combine your pizza meetup with strolls around Central Park or evening walks along Amsterdam Avenue, enriching your meetup with a full day of socializing indoors and outdoors. The friendly staff and efficient service also mean less waiting and more time for your group to connect. Some groups enjoy pairing their meal with light beverages they bring along or take advantage of any nearby cafés or juice bars for drinks to complement their pizza feast.
Why is Made In New York Pizza perfect for hosting a family or friends meetup?
Made In New York Pizza suits family gatherings or friend meetups due to its welcoming, informal environment that breaks down social barriers and encourages togetherness. The menu, while centered on pizza, caters to a variety of preferences including vegetarian options, ensuring everyone can find something they enjoy. The affordable pricing means you can feed a crowd without breaking the bank, an essential consideration when hosting larger groups. Having a location in the vibrant Upper West Side means after your meal, you can easily explore local attractions, making your meetup more adventurous and memorable. The large selection of pizza slices served fresh and fast also accommodates groups that may want to eat at different paces or pick up orders to go without holding back others. Families value the place for kid-friendly portions and quick service, while friend groups appreciate the balance of quality and convenience.
What types of pizza can you expect and how do they appeal to group tastes?
Made In New York Pizza specializes in authentic New York–style pizza, known for its thin, crispy crusts that hold up under generous toppings without becoming soggy. The standout offering is the square pepperoni slice, which features crispy pepperoni cups that add texture and bursts of flavor, perfect for sharing among friends who want to try something classic yet distinct. The white pizza, which skips the tomato sauce for a creamy, cheesy experience, serves as a great alternative for those looking to mix it up. Their “upside-down” slice, topped with a sweeter tomato sauce on top, offers a unique taste twist for adventurous eaters. This variety ensures that a group can order multiple slices to sample and compare, making the meal an interactive and engaging experience. The pizza uses high-quality cheeses and fresh ingredients, promising a taste consistent with New York’s legendary pizza reputation. This variety caters well to mixed groups where preferences and dietary needs vary.
How does the location and ambiance enhance the group experience?
Situated at 421 Amsterdam Avenue at 80th Street, Made In New York Pizza benefits from a prime Upper West Side location that is both accessible and vibrant. The neighborhood’s energetic yet comfortable vibe translates into a casual dining space where friendships can thrive over great food. The pizzeria offers adequate seating, perfect for groups who want to eat on-site and make an occasion out of lunch or dinner. The space is wheelchair accessible, expanding inclusivity for all guests. By being open late (until 11 pm), it offers flexibility for meetups that extend into the evening, whether for dinner or a late-night snack after events or shows nearby. The Upper West Side’s blend of residential charm and cultural hotspots means that visits to Made In New York Pizza can be conveniently paired with other social or recreational outings, turning a simple pizza meetup into an enriching group experience.
What do customer reviews reveal about the meetup potential?
Customer reviews consistently highlight Made In New York Pizza’s excellent pizza taste, fast and professional service, and friendly atmosphere—all crucial factors for group meetups. Reviews mention how the pizza “feels like the best in New York” from the perspective of locals and even visiting Italians, confirming its authentic quality and appeal. Users also emphasize the value for money and the inviting vibe that makes it a comfortable place to gather. While some reviews note differences in quality between dine-in and delivery, the on-site experience appears particularly praised for creating a communal environment. The overall rating of 4.6 stars from well over a thousand reviews signals broad, enthusiastic customer satisfaction, underscoring that many groups and families have enjoyed their visits and returned multiple times.
How convenient is Made In New York Pizza for group logistics?
Made In New York Pizza’s straightforward menu, ordering options, and location simplify meetup planning considerably. The Upper West Side site accepts credit cards, offers takeout and delivery, and has seating to accommodate various group sizes. This flexibility supports group preferences whether you want to eat in together, pick up food to enjoy in a nearby park, or even order delivery to a separate meetup venue. Its hours from 11 am to 11 pm provide ample windows to fit diverse schedules, including late dinners. The restaurant’s reputation for quick service means minimal wait times, which is crucial for groups keen to start their gathering without fuss. Located on a major avenue with public transportation access, it is easy for friends or family members coming from different parts of the city to coordinate arrival, enhancing the overall convenience of organizing a stress-free meetup.
What makes Made In New York Pizza stand out from other local pizzerias for meetups?
While New York City abounds with pizza options, Made In New York Pizza differentiates itself through its blend of authenticity, quality, and welcoming atmosphere tailored for group interaction. The pepperoni slice with crispy cups is a notable signature that sets it apart for those who appreciate classic New York slices with a twist. Its solid reputation among locals and visitors alike, along with competitive prices, make it a reliable choice without sacrificing flavor or experience. The pizzeria’s focus on fresh, natural ingredients delivered in generous portions suits groups looking to share, indulge, and create lasting social memories. Additionally, the friendliness of staff and comfortable seating arrangements help foster a convivial environment. Unlike some places that prioritize fast takeaway only, Made In New York Pizza invites groups to linger, enjoy, and bond over slices that capture the essence of the city’s pizza heritage. This balance of quality, authenticity, and atmosphere uniquely positions it as an excellent venue for social gatherings.
What other local activities complement a meetup at Made In New York Pizza?
Because Made In New York Pizza is located in the culturally rich Upper West Side, your pizza meetup can easily extend into other social or recreational activities. After eating, groups can stroll through Central Park to digest and enjoy the scenic beauty together. Nearby museums, bookstores, and theaters offer plenty of options for post-meal entertainment, making it possible to design a full day of friendship and fun around a simple pizza meal. The neighborhood also has bustling cafes and dessert spots, perfect for grabbing coffee or sweet treats to round out your meetup experience. The accessible location means you can plan walks or visits to iconic NYC sites, making your group outing multifaceted and memorable beyond just the dining aspect. These opportunities enhance the value of choosing Made In New York Pizza as your meetup spot, ensuring it’s not just about food but the entire experience of sharing time in New York City with those you care about.
How does the food quality at Made In New York Pizza support repeated group visits?
The high-quality, fresh ingredients used in Made In New York Pizza’s slices are a major reason groups keep returning. Using NYC’s legendary water for dough, quality cheeses, and fresh toppings creates a flavor profile that avid pizza lovers recognize and appreciate. The consistency in taste and quality, whether you opt for the classic pepperoni or the white pizza, supports repeat visits because groups can rely on a satisfying experience every time. Positive reviews from locals and tourists alike attest to the durability of their reputation and food excellence. This reliability is key when planning group meetups, as guests expect and receive great pizza that pleases diverse palates. As a result, Made In New York Pizza becomes a go-to destination where shared enjoyment of food strengthens bonds and creates traditions for friends and family gathering around every slice.