When asking yourself about something to do near me in New York with a group of friends or family, consider
My Pie Pizzeria Romana
Why My Pie Pizzeria Romana is a fun option when searching for things to do near me with friends and family
My Pie Pizzeria Romana is a standout destination for pizza lovers in Midtown Manhattan, specializing in Roman-style pizza that delivers a unique twist on a classic favorite. Located conveniently on Lexington Avenue, this pizzeria is prized for its square, thin-crust pizza slices that feature a crispy crust and rich, flavorful sauce, making for a delightful eating experience. The restaurant offers a cozy ambiance and welcoming service, making it an excellent spot to gather with friends for a casual lunch or dinner. The menu caters to a variety of tastes, including vegetarian and vegan options, ensuring that most dietary preferences can be accommodated. Known for quick service, the establishment is perfect for those looking to enjoy high-quality pizza either at the venue or through takeout and delivery options. Friendly staff and a well-maintained environment add to its appeal as a comfortable and lively place to meet and share great food.
Here's what people think of My Pie Pizzeria Romana
As of recent, My Pie Pizzeria Romana holds a 4.7-star rating based on 1617 reviews.
Reviews for My Pie Pizzeria Romana reflect an overall positive reception, with an impressive 4.7 rating from over 1600 reviews. Many customers praised the quality of the pizza, highlighting the crispy crust and the flavorful tomato sauce as standouts. Positive reviews often mention the margherita pizza as superior to the standard cheese slice, appreciating the unique texture and satisfying taste. The quick delivery and high-end feel of the pizzas were also frequently cited as positives. However, some negative feedback points to inconsistencies in pizza temperature and texture, with a few reviewers finding the crust undercooked or the cheese overly chewy. A common critique relates to certain toppings and pizzas being soggy or doughy, and some felt that the sauce leaned towards being slightly sweet. Despite these minor flaws, many customers appreciate the friendly service and pleasant ambiance which enhance their dining experience. Overall, the reviews portray My Pie Pizzeria Romana as a reliable spot for great Roman pizza with a few aspects that could be improved upon, but one that remains a favorite for quick, tasty Italian cuisine in New York City.
Highlights from reviewers (Most Relevant)
Lauren Helene
My favorite spot to grab a slice of pizza in NY! I love the crispiness of the crust, the variety of flavors, and how generous they are with every topping. Plus, the staff here are super friendly and go out of their way to provide a good experience! I only get to come every 3-6 months because I live out of state but they somehow remember me every time, which is always a nice feeling. The last time I was here, I came a little after the dinner rush and was disappointed that they had run out of my favorite flavor - and they offered to make me a pie fresh! The inside only has 5 small tables so it can get a little crowded during a rush but they have great to go boxes so you can enjoy your slices on the go or in one of the many nearby parks.
Mark DeVito
Went in around 5:25 PM on a Saturday—no wait, quick service. The slices are big and filling, about $7 each. I had the buffalo chicken, and my wife got the truffle mushroom—both were excellent. Crispy, airy crust with plenty of toppings, exactly what you want from Roman-style pizza. Chill vibe, friendly staff. Definitely worth stopping in if you’re nearby.
Linda M
Good value. Interesting flavors. The Buffalo chicken ($7) had a spicy but salty sauce - there was a substantial amount of chicken. The dough is a little chewy. The crust was a crispy. The truffle mushroom pizza had a fair amount of mushroom ($6) but could have used more truffle oil. The warmed up pizza was not hot enough. Annoying. The rectangular pizza was filling enough and a good size for a snack. 2 slices would make it a meal. $14 total with tax. A reasonable price for a meal in midtown Manhattan. April 2025.
Shreya R
I’m not the biggest fan of a thick crust, but these pizza crusts were thankfully the exact consistency of focaccia and had a beautifully webbed crusting (as if excess cheese had cooked on the edges). Otherwise, these were okay pizza slices. I loved the rectangular shape of the slices, though.
Hannah W
At 3 pm I was just looking for a quick snack so I ordered one slice of Truffle Oil and Mushroom - OMG it tasted HEAVENLY!!! When my husband joined me (he'd had lunch elsewhere) I would not share a single bite with him :-). Most of their pizzas are vegetarian, which really suit me. It's a very small place, just a few two person tables, but super cozy. The server was very friendly, and explained to me that the slice of my choice was indeed vegetarian, that it only contained mushrooms, truffle oil and cheese. If I happen to be in that part of town again, this would be my first choice for a quick bite and I am eager to try out other varieties.
How to reach My Pie Pizzeria Romana
None
Website: None
Why My Pie Pizzeria Romana may become Your Favorite Meetup Place for Catching Up, Celebrating or Just Hanging Out
Why rally at My Pie Pizzeria Romana with your friends? Because this pizzeria offers a unique blend of authentic Roman pizza flavor, a welcoming ambiance, and excellent service — the perfect setting for gathering with loved ones. Whether you and your friends are pizza connoisseurs or just looking for a delicious and satisfying meal, My Pie Pizzeria Romana boasts a 4.7-star rating from over 1,600 reviews, reflecting its popularity and consistent quality. Their pizzas stand out for their crispy yet slightly chewy crust, reminiscent of traditional Roman style, paired with flavorful toppings and perfectly balanced sauce. This combination of quality food and the inviting atmosphere makes it an exceptional place to relax and enjoy a meal together. Additionally, its prime Midtown East location on Lexington Avenue provides easy access, making logistics simple for any group meetup. The friendly, attentive staff ensure your party feels welcomed and well cared for, enhancing the social experience. For anyone searching for a place to enjoy great pizza in a comfortable setting that fosters connection and conversations, rallying at My Pie with friends is an excellent choice.
What activities make My Pie Pizzeria Romana perfect for a group meetup? Primarily, the shared experience of savoring expertly crafted Roman-style pizzas encourages conversation and camaraderie around the table. The pizza is served in square slices cut in half, allowing for easy sharing and exploration of multiple flavors among friends. This enhances the social dynamic, as everyone can try a variety of toppings without ordering entire individual pies. Beyond the main dishes, the menu also offers delectable desserts like chocolate mousse and tiramisu, giving groups a sweet ending to their meal, which is perfect for those who want to linger and chat over dessert. The ambiance itself supports group gatherings — it is cozy, with an inviting vibe yet bustling enough to feel lively. Though seating is somewhat limited, the staff manages space well, and group orders, including takeout and delivery, are handled efficiently, ensuring your meetup is seamless whether dining in or out. Fast, friendly service keeps the experience smooth and enjoyable, vital when coordinating larger parties. All these aspects combine to make My Pie Pizzeria Romana a flexible, fun, and delicious venue for any group meetup.
How does My Pie Pizzeria Romana’s menu cater to different tastes in a group? The menu features a variety of pizza options with diverse toppings and cheese blends that appeal to all palates, from classic Margherita to adventurous choices like eggplant and pepperoni. This variety ensures that vegetarians, meat lovers, and those with simpler tastes all find something satisfying. The crust strikes a balance between crispiness and chewiness, a signature of Roman-style pizza, which distinguishes My Pie from other pizzerias and adds to the authentic dining experience. For groups who enjoy tasting different styles, the ability to order multiple slice varieties encourages sharing and tasting, turning the meal into a culinary exploration. The addition of delightful desserts rounds out the menu and offers an inviting option for finishing the evening on a sweet note. Furthermore, the high quality and freshness of ingredients elevate the flavors, making it a memorable dining experience that groups can bond over. This thoughtful mix of menu options and attention to detail in preparation is what makes My Pie ideal for a group with diverse tastes.
Why is the ambiance at My Pie Pizzeria Romana ideal for friends and family gatherings? The restaurant strikes a balance between cozy and vibrant, creating an atmosphere that feels welcoming without being too loud or chaotic. This kind of ambiance encourages relaxed conversations and a leisurely meal, essential for a successful group gathering. The décor combines a casual urban feel with touches that reflect the Roman pizzeria heritage, adding authenticity and charm. Despite its Midtown East location, the restaurant maintains a neighborhood pizzeria vibe, making visitors feel immediately at home. Staff friendliness is frequently highlighted by customers, which contributes significantly to a warm environment where groups feel valued and comfortable. Though the seating capacity is limited, the layout is designed to accommodate groups without sacrificing comfort or service quality. Overall, the ambiance supports socializing and enjoyment, making it easier for groups to focus on each other while enjoying excellent food and drink.
How does service at My Pie Pizzeria Romana enhance the group dining experience? Service here is known for being prompt, friendly, and attentive, crucial factors when dining with friends or family. The team works efficiently to manage orders, even for large groups or multiple pie requests, whether dining in or ordering delivery. Customers frequently commend the pleasantness of the staff, noting how they make the experience smoother through helpful recommendations and accommodating needs. Quick service ensures that your group doesn't have to wait long for their food, keeping energy high and the mood positive. For those who prefer to order ahead or take food to share elsewhere, My Pie handles delivery with care, ensuring pizzas arrive hot and fresh. This reliability makes it a dependable choice for groups who want to avoid hassle but still enjoy high-quality Italian cuisine together. Attentive service paired with quality food helps turn an ordinary outing into a memorable social event.
What makes the location of My Pie Pizzeria Romana convenient for group meetups? Situated at 690 Lexington Avenue in Midtown East, New York City, My Pie is easy to reach for friends and family coming from different parts of the city. The area is well served by public transportation, and the central location also makes it a practical stop for those combining dining with other activities in midtown Manhattan. Having a reliable pizza spot in such a bustling neighborhood adds a layer of convenience since groups don’t have to stray far for a great meal. The neighborhood itself offers various amenities for before or after your meetup, such as nearby coffee shops, parks, and cultural attractions, allowing for a full day or evening out. Parking options, while limited as typical in Manhattan, are manageable for those who drive. This central, accessible spot means less travel stress and more time enjoying each other’s company—which is key for successful group gatherings.
In summary, My Pie Pizzeria Romana stands out as an exceptional venue for socially connecting over food. Its authentic Roman pizza, diverse menu options, cozy yet lively ambiance, attentive service, and prime Midtown Manhattan location collectively create a perfect environment for friends and families. Whether seeking a casual lunch, dinner, or a spot for celebratory get-togethers, this pizzeria offers everything needed to make a group meetup enjoyable, memorable, and delicious. The positive reviews and stellar reputation underscore its value as a go-to pizza destination in New York City.