Discover My Way Tavern: Holly Springs' Premier Spot for Food, Drinks, and Fun in Raleigh, North Carolina
Written and verified by the Rallyvite editorial team using publicly available data and the business’s official website. Last updated: 26 Dec 2025 11:59
TL;DR: My Way Tavern Bar Hop is One of the Best Group Outing Venues near Raleigh
My Way Tavern in Holly Springs is a welcoming neighborhood tavern that offers an exceptional gathering place for friends and families looking to enjoy great food, drinks, and a lively atmosphere. Owned and operated by Andrew and Nikki Stafford, this establishment features a unique horseshoe-style bar made from reclaimed 158-year-old barn wood, giving it a rustic yet cozy ambiance perfect for socializing. The tavern prides itself on an extensive selection of local craft beers, with 19 drafts and over 80 bottled beers, many brewed in North Carolina, ensuring beer lovers have a plentiful variety to sample. The menu focuses on all-American comfort food made fresh daily, including standout dishes like the Tavern Mushroom Meatloaf and Cajun Chicken, along with popular appetizers, salads, soups, burgers, and sandwiches. Regular patrons especially appreciate the homemade dressings, tender wings, and the highly praised fries, which are considered "the best in the neighborhood." Beyond great food and drink, My Way Tavern offers exciting weekly events such as Hammered Trivia, live music, and music bingo, providing entertainment that fosters camaraderie and fun. With both indoor and outdoor seating, it caters to different moods and occasions, making it an ideal spot for casual meetups or celebrations. Friendly service combined with unbeatable prices rounds out the experience, making My Way Tavern a favored local retreat in Holly Springs.
Table of Contents
What people think of My Way Tavern, based on reviews
As of recent, My Way Tavern holds a 4.5-star rating based on 1086 reviews.
Customers consistently mention in reviews that My Way Tavern delivers a well-rounded experience complimenting both its food and atmosphere. Many appreciate the tavern's large and varied menu, which includes a specials lunch menu and an impressive selection of craft beers. Positive reviews highlight the homemade dressings, quality chicken wings, robust clam chowder, and generous sandwich portions. The friendly staff and the lively bar environment with frequent events like trivia nights and live music contribute to a vibrant hangout spot. Customers also enjoy the tavern's unique rustic bar centerpiece and the welcoming local vibe that the staff helps cultivate. However, some negative feedback points to occasional inconsistencies with food seasoning, such as over-salted dishes or heavy sauces, and comments on the tavern sometimes being loud, especially during busy periods or special events. A few guests have noted disappointment when service was not as prompt or personalized as expected. Despite these instances, the general consensus is that My Way Tavern remains a dependable choice for casual dining and drinking, offering good value and a community-oriented atmosphere. The balance of positive experiences over occasional negatives has maintained the tavern’s strong reputation and its impressive 4.5-star rating based on over a thousand reviews, underscoring its popularity and local favorite status.
How to reach My Way Tavern
522 St Marys St, Raleigh, NC 27605, USA
FAQ about My Way Tavern, your new favorite meetup place for groups in Raleigh, North Carolina
My Way Tavern offers an inviting atmosphere that makes it the perfect locale to gather and reconnect with friends or family. The cozy and relaxed environment is paired with a large, signature horseshoe-style bar made from reclaimed barn wood, giving the place a warm, rustic charm. The location is renowned for its welcoming, friendly staff focused on exceptional customer service, setting the tone for an enjoyable and hassle-free group outing. Rated impressively at 4.5 stars from over a thousand reviews, My Way Tavern is consistently praised for its combination of delicious, freshly made American dishes and an extensive selection of local and craft beers. This balance of great food, excellent drinks, and an easy-going vibe helps make every meetup feel special and memorable. Whether you want a casual evening of food and drinks or a lively night filled with games and live music, My Way Tavern caters perfectly to groups seeking a social and entertaining backdrop for their gatherings.
The tavern boasts an exciting array of activities designed to keep groups engaged and entertained throughout their visit. One of the standout weekly events is the Hammered Trivia night, which is celebrated as the best trivia night in Wake County. It invites groups to team up and test their knowledge in a fun, competitive environment, making it ideal for friends and families who want some light-hearted entertainment alongside their meals. Another fan favorite is Music Bingo on Tuesdays, a lively event where attendees can enjoy music-themed bingo sessions enhanced by the venue's spirited crowd and vibrant energy. Fridays bring live music performances, enriching the evening with local bands that elevate the ambiance and encourage dancing or just casual listening. These planned events provide a dynamic social experience beyond food and drink, enabling patrons to create shared memories and enjoy interactive entertainment together in a cozy yet lively setting.
My Way Tavern offers a diverse and extensive menu that caters to a variety of tastes, perfect for groups looking to share and explore different dishes. The menu features all-American staples, including standout dishes like Red Zinfandel Braised Ribs, My Way Cajun Chicken, Tavern Mushroom Meatloaf, and hearty sandwiches like The Noonan (a chicken salad sandwich on sourdough). Appetizers such as wings, tenders, and some of the best fries in the neighborhood are highly recommended for sharing with friends. The tavern takes pride in fresh, made-from-scratch offerings including house-made dressings for salads and daily specials that reflect quality and variety. On the drinks side, guests can enjoy a robust selection of over 19 draft beers in Holly Springs and more than 22 in Fuquay-Varina, with 15 of those being locally brewed in North Carolina. With over 80 bottled beers, a fully stocked bar, and a wide range of cocktails and spirits, My Way Tavern provides both a variety and quality that appeals to beer connoisseurs and casual drinkers alike, enhancing group experiences with carefully curated drink options.
The tavern’s design and ambiance are deliberately crafted to encourage social interaction and enjoyment among groups. The central horseshoe bar acts as a natural gathering spot, made from historic reclaimed wood, promoting an intimate and communal feeling where groups can congregate closely. The casual sports bar vibe is complimented with enough seating options for both large and small parties, including indoor and outdoor areas that allow for relaxed or lively meetups depending on the group's mood. The friendly, attentive staff contribute significantly to the tavern’s welcoming aura, ensuring that guests feel at ease and catered to. Moreover, the venue’s lively events like trivia, music bingo, and live music create opportunities for shared experiences and team collaboration, whether friends are competing or cheering together. This combination of well-thought-out design, warm service, and engaging entertainment solidifies My Way Tavern as an excellent hub for creating joyful social experiences.
Frequent visitors praise My Way Tavern not just for its food and drinks, but for a consistent atmosphere that feels like a hometown retreat. Locals highlight the reliability of the menu and the level of service—many mention never being disappointed after multiple visits. The tavern is considered a community staple where people can unwind without pretense, often describing it as their "go-to spot" because of how well it balances quality with comfort. With daily opening hours from 11 a.m. to midnight, it is convenient for both lunch meetups and late-night hangouts. The location’s dedication to providing unbeatable food at great prices combined with numerous local beers on tap also makes it budget-friendly for groups looking to enjoy a full evening out. This reputation and steady popularity clarify why many choose to celebrate important events or simply share casual evenings at My Way Tavern.
My Way Tavern’s central locations in Holly Springs and Fuquay-Varina are easily reachable neighborhoods with ample parking and comfortable seating arrangements suited for groups of various sizes. Operating seven days a week from mid-morning into the late evening allows flexibility, accommodating different schedules from weekend brunches to weekday dinners or after-work gatherings. Reservations and friendly staff assist in group coordination, making organization smooth and pleasant. Furthermore, the tavern's focus on group-friendly menu options and its well-stocked bar reduce wait times and streamline service, ensuring groups can relax and enjoy their time without hassle. The tavern’s online presence, including a user-friendly website with event calendars and contact info, simplifies planning ahead. Altogether, these elements combine to guarantee a stress-free and enjoyable meetup environment.
Whether it's trivia nights, music bingo, live bands, or simply indulging in well-prepared comfort food alongside local brews, this tavern provides an all-encompassing experience that fosters connection, laughter, and lasting memories. Its reputation as a beloved local hub underscores exactly why it is the ideal spot to rally and celebrate any occasion with those who matter most.