When asking yourself about something to do near me in Chicago with a group of friends or family, consider
PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO
Why PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO is a fun option when searching for things to do near me with friends and family
Proper Pizza Chicago is a popular pizzeria located at 2459 North Halsted Street in Chicago, Illinois, offering a unique and inviting atmosphere that makes it an excellent place to meet up with friends. This pizzeria is celebrated for its innovative approach to traditional Chicago-style pizza, featuring distinct toppings and crust options like sesame seeds that add a flavorful twist to familiar favorites. Aside from their signature pizzas, the menu also includes options such as garlic cheesy bread, salads like the crisp Caesar, and even special offerings during holidays, such as free Nutella with certain pizza orders. The setting provides a comfortable space where guests can enjoy delicious slices along with great company. Their commitment to quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations enhances the overall dining experience, making it suitable for casual outings or celebrations. Whether you prefer classic cheese or more adventurous combinations like truffle or tuna topping pizzas, Proper Pizza Chicago provides an accommodating menu to satisfy diverse preferences. Its neighborhood location in Chicago's vibrant Halsted corridor makes it accessible and a local favorite spot for pizza enthusiasts searching for a new take on a beloved staple.
Here's what people think of PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO
As of recent, PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO holds a 4.7-star rating based on 371 reviews.
Proper Pizza Chicago holds a strong rating of approximately 4.7 out of 5 based on around 370 reviews, reflecting generally positive customer reception. Many reviewers praise the taste of the pizza, highlighting the great atmosphere that complements their dining experience. Positive feedback often mentions the delicious slices, unique crust options like sesame seeds, and the friendly, fast service that enhances the overall visit. The diverse menu options and consistent quality appear well-received, contributing to its reputation as a favored pizza spot in the area. On the other hand, some negative reviews point out occasional issues such as soggy crusts or toppings that did not meet expectations, including comments about certain mushrooms tasting canned. A few reviewers also feel that some pizzas fall short of traditional Chicago pizza standards. Despite these critiques, the majority of guests seem to enjoy their visit and appreciate the distinct flavors offered. In conclusion, while not every detail perfectly satisfies all patrons, Proper Pizza Chicago maintains a strong appeal through its creative menu, inviting environment, and generally high-quality offerings, making it a worthwhile destination for pizza lovers in Chicago.
Highlights from reviewers (Most Relevant)
Jabari Hunter
The Owner is a really kind and chill man. Has a nice lowkey vibe to it which I was surprised there weren't more people there. Could feed 2 on $16. If you're looking for something cheap with nice vibes walk a little more to come to this place.
July B
Proper Pizza Chicago: A Culinary Gem Proper Pizza Chicago has swiftly earned a reputation as a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts in the city. Specializing in thin crust pizzas, this establishment stands out with its innovative use of fresh ingredients and unique addition of sesame seeds, offering a delightful twist to a classic favorite.The thin crust is perfectly crisp, providing a satisfying base for an array of toppings that burst with flavor. The freshness of the ingredients is evident in every bite, showcasing a commitment to quality that sets Proper Pizza Chicago apart from the rest. The sesame seeds sprinkled on the crust add an unexpected yet delightful crunch, enhancing the overall taste and texture in a way that is both surprising and pleasing. This inventive touch speaks to the creativity and culinary expertise of the team behind Proper Pizza Chicago. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Proper Pizza Chicago is highly recommended for anyone eager to experience a unique and delicious Pizza.
Jennifer Cary
The flavors and the crust are so good. It’s my favorite pizza in the city which I know is a tall comment. I do recommend eating it hot as it’s best that way! The only issue is the price is pretty high, but the flavors are so good and you can tell they are using high quality products. Recommendation would be to get the website updated. We always have issues ordering, for example, tonight we couldn’t order the special where we get a free dessert pizza. So we went on without it.
Steve Hanks
Stopped in for a slice of sausage pizza and a coke. Cool atmoshere! Different than any other pizza place you've been to. I wanted to like the pizza, but I closed my eyes and tasted the first bite and I was brought back to middle school lunch pizza. The kind the lunch ladies with hair nets used to bake on the big rectangular medal pans. Not bad, but not a pizza I would be happy paying 30 bucks for.
Christian Van Brimmer
Where do I begin with this horrific experience?? Avoid this place at all costs. My friend thought that due to the high reviews, it would be worth checking out. Boy were we wrong. I got two slices and a coke. Fine. They were ok- good, but not great. My friend orders a slice, a salad and a beer. While being rung up, she notices the salad comes up as $12.99. On the hard copy menus on the tables, it says a Caesar Salad is $10, with chicken $12. She tells the cashier that she doesn’t want the salad if it isn’t the price listed on the menu. He then accuses her of coming in before and not paying and proceeds to take away her drink and slice. Neither of us have been here before and she says that he is mistaken. She just doesn’t want the salad at the higher price. He clearly doesn’t know how to delete an item off the ticket and says she can’t have any food until the manager comes in a few minutes to fix it. Unbelievable. Fix the ticket and let her pay, except he doesn’t know how to do that. He then says the manager is coming in 10 minutes. While my friend is waiting, I share one of my slices with her and then offer to get her one. I go up to order another slice, he complies and tries to ring me up. He goes tobthe only register tablet where my friend’s order remains, unpaid. I can see the ticket on the screen. He adds my slice to her ticket, tries to do something and then adds another slice to the ticket. He then tells me the manager should be here soon and can fix it and I can pay then. It is about 7pm at that time. I got my slices at 6:41, so this has been going on about 20 minutes already. We finish our food, assuming this manager is showing up soon so everything can be settled. We finish around 7:30. Give them until about 8pm and go up to ask where this manager is as we have been there for nearly 90 minutes. The guy says no manager is coming. Well, thanks for letting us know that fact and he asks if I have cash to cover the slice I picked up for my friend. Luckily I do, but why didn’t you communicate this about 30 minutes ago. No apology, nothing. This was a failure on so many levels. First, the cashier is clearly not capable of operating a simple and modern POS system. I am in the service industry and have managed many a cash register, old and modern. Second, don’t accuse my friend of not paying previously when neither of us have never been there or of not paying now because you don’t know how to run the register and delete an unwanted item. Third, charge what your physical menu says. That’s false advertising. I included photos of what the menu on the table says versus what is online for reference. Fourth, we could have been made aware that no one was coming so we didn’t hang out for an extra half an hour. This is no way to run a neighborhood business. I work very close to this establishment and will be telling this story to everyone. A very emphatic thumbs down for this place.
How to reach PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO
None
Website: None
Why PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO may become Your Favorite Meetup Place for Catching Up, Celebrating or Just Hanging Out
Why rally at PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO with your friends? Because it offers a vibrant yet cozy Chicago dining experience centered around what many consider a universal crowd-pleaser—exceptional pizza. This spot perfectly balances the feel of an urban hangout with an authentic pizza joint vibe, making it ideal for groups seeking both quality food and a lively atmosphere. Friends looking for a place to catch up over mouthwatering pizza slices prepared with care will find PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO hits the mark. The establishment boasts a strong reputation with a 4.7-star rating from 371 reviews, reflecting both popularity and consistent quality; it’s not just a place to eat, but a destination to create memorable moments. Whether you want to kick back after work, celebrate a casual occasion, or simply gather for a weekend pizza night, the inviting ambiance fosters easy conversation and fun. The thin, crispy crust and fresh ingredients serve as the delicious foundation for shared enjoyment, while the friendly, attentive service ensures your group feels well taken care of throughout your visit.
What activities can your group enjoy at PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO? Aside from savoring their renowned pizzas, the venue is well-suited for several casual group-oriented activities that make meetups feel special and engaging. First, there is the dining experience itself—sharing a variety of pizzas encourages communal tasting and lively debates over favorites. The menu offers a unique sesame crust option, setting it apart and providing a conversation starter about flavors and preferences. Groups can order multiple pies, complementing each other’s choices and creating a pizza sampler experience. Beyond food, the atmosphere is conducive to casual games or socializing, with enough seating to accommodate medium-sized groups comfortably. Conversations flow easily in the warm setting, making it a great place for both old friends catching up and new acquaintances getting to know each other. The location in the vibrant Lincoln Park neighborhood adds a cultural touch, allowing your meetup to extend into nearby attractions or bars if desired. With delivery and takeout options also available, your gathering can continue in comfort elsewhere while still enjoying the same great food.
Why is PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO perfect for a group meetup? Its spacious layout, casual but stylish decor, and commitment to quality food converge to create an ideal social dining environment. The thin, crispy pizzas use fresh toppings and stand out from typical “cracker crust” styles, impressing pizza lovers with authenticity and flavor. This attention to detail signals a place that values its craft, reassuring groups that their meal will be satisfying and memorable. The 4.7-star rating across hundreds of reviews speaks to consistent excellence, an important factor when coordinating meetups that hinge on a good dining experience. Additionally, the venue’s location on North Halsted Street offers easy accessibility and parking options, important logistical considerations for group gatherings. PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO’s staff are noted for friendly, responsive service, making patrons feel welcome and valued—key to keeping a relaxed, enjoyable atmosphere. Whether your group opts for a midday lunch or an evening feast, the balance of quality, comfort, and community makes this pizzeria a standout spot for social occasions.
What do the pizza offerings at PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO bring to the table? The menu is centered on expertly crafted thin-crust pizzas praised for their crispy texture and quality ingredients. This goes beyond a basic slice, with options including the unique sesame crust that has earned attention for its distinctive taste and appeal. The cheese is consistently described as rich and flavorful, complementing fresh toppings that range from classic pepperoni to more adventurous selections. Some customers have noted slight variations in certain ingredients like mushrooms, but overall the pizzas receive high marks for taste and presentation. This variety allows groups to tailor their orders to diverse preferences, accommodating meat lovers, vegetarians, or those simply looking for classic combinations. The overall pizza quality lends itself well to sharing, sparking friendly exchanges about personal favorites and encouraging communal enjoyment. Pairing pizzas with their salad options and beverages makes a complete meal experience, encouraging longer stays and deeper connection among friends.
How does PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO’s ambiance enhance group gatherings? The space translates the energetic spirit of Chicago’s Lincoln Park area into a comfortable venue where people feel at ease. The informal yet clean and inviting decor encourages relaxed conversation without distractions. This makes it conducive to both casual hangouts and more planned events, such as birthday dinners or informal celebrations. The lighting and layout promote inclusivity and interaction, ensuring everyone at the table can participate in the meetup. Music and noise levels strike a friendly balance, fostering a buzz that energizes while allowing voices to be heard clearly. The seating arrangements are flexible enough to accommodate different group sizes, whether a handful of friends or a larger family gathering. Regular patrons often comment on the welcoming service and the way staff contribute to a positive group dynamic. These elements combine to ensure that your meetup isn’t just about the pizza—it’s about the experience around the table.
What else makes PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO an excellent meetup choice? Convenience and versatility are important facets. The restaurant offers takeout and delivery options for groups preferring to meet outside the pizzeria but still enjoy its famous pies. This flexibility allows for spontaneous get-togethers or larger events where logistics might challenge an in-person visit. Being located in a bustling neighborhood means there are ample post-meal activities nearby, from bars to parks, enabling groups to extend their outing seamlessly. The strong community feel also attracts a diverse crowd, giving meetups a lively, authentic city vibe rather than a sterile chain restaurant atmosphere. Finally, the price point is accessible without sacrificing quality, making it easy for friends or family to enjoy a night out without stress. Overall, PROPER PIZZA CHICAGO stands out not just as a place to eat but as a focal point for social connection, cultivating an environment where great food and great company come together naturally.